Your Source For What's on Stage in the New York Area

Show or theatre
Show or theatre Search by date
Advanced Search

New York Theatre Review Round-Up Of Shows Currently Playing

Theatre In New York lists the reviews from over 100 different New York area publications. We currently have reviews listed for 15 shows now playing, and a total of 228 different reviews!!!

& Juliet

& Juliet

The New York Times - Somewhat Recommended

Vulture - Somewhat Recommended

New York Theater - Somewhat Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

New York Post - Somewhat Recommended

amNY - Somewhat Recommended

Time Out New York - Recommended

TheaterMania - Somewhat Recommended

Broadway Blog - Recommended

Stage Buddy - Highly Recommended

Daily Beast - Somewhat Recommended

The Observer - Not Recommended

Broadway News - Recommended

Theatrely - Somewhat Recommended

New York Stage Review - Recommended

(15 Reviews)
Stephen Sondheim Theatre

Aladdin

Aladdin

The New York Times - Recommended

NY Daily News - Somewhat Recommended

Associated Press - Highly Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Recommended

Vulture - Recommended

NY1 - Highly Recommended

Variety - Somewhat Recommended

USA Today - Highly Recommended

New York Post - Recommended

Entertainment Weekly - Recommended

Newsday - Highly Recommended

NBC New York - Recommended

Time Out New York - Recommended

The Wrap - Not Recommended

Financial Times - Recommended

New Jersey Newsroom - Highly Recommended

Talkin Broadway - Not Recommended

Cititour.com - Highly Recommended

TheaterMania - Highly Recommended

NewYorkTheater.me - Recommended

(20 Reviews)
New Amsterdam Theatre

The Book Of Mormon

The Book Of Mormon

The New York Times - Highly Recommended

NY Daily News - Highly Recommended

Associated Press - Highly Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Highly Recommended

NY1 - Highly Recommended

Bloomberg - Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

USA Today - Highly Recommended

New York Post - Highly Recommended

Entertainment Weekly - Highly Recommended

Newsday - Highly Recommended

amNY - Highly Recommended

Wall Street Journal - Somewhat Recommended

Washington Post - Highly Recommended

Chicago Tribune - Highly Recommended

Time Out New York - Highly Recommended

NY Magazine - Highly Recommended

Village Voice - Recommended

Backstage - Highly Recommended

Los Angeles Times - Highly Recommended

New Jersey Newsroom - Highly Recommended

Theatre Is Easy - Highly Recommended

(22 Reviews)
Eugene O'Neill Theatre

Buena Vista Social Club

Buena Vista Social Club

New York Post - Recommended

(1 Review)
Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre

Chicago

Chicago

The New York Times - Highly Recommended

NY Daily News - Highly Recommended

Associated Press - Highly Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Highly Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

USA Today - Recommended

Entertainment Weekly - Highly Recommended

Bergen Record - Highly Recommended

Newsday - Highly Recommended

Chicago Tribune - Somewhat Recommended

Time Magazine - Highly Recommended

Philadelphia Inquirer - Highly Recommended

Newhouse News Service - Highly Recommended

CurtainUp - Highly Recommended

Talkin Broadway - Highly Recommended

TheaterMania - Recommended

(16 Reviews)
Ambassador Theatre

Hadestown

Hadestown

The New York Times - Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Recommended

Vulture - Somewhat Recommended

New York Theater - Recommended

amNY - Somewhat Recommended

Time Out New York - Highly Recommended

The Wrap - Somewhat Recommended

Village Voice - Recommended

Financial Times - Somewhat Recommended

Deadline - Recommended

CurtainUp - Highly Recommended

Talkin Broadway - Somewhat Recommended

Cititour.com - Highly Recommended

TheaterMania - Highly Recommended

Huffington Post - Somewhat Recommended

Theatre Reviews Limited - Highly Recommended

Broadway Blog - Somewhat Recommended

Stage Buddy - Highly Recommended

Front Row Center - Highly Recommended

Bobs Theater Blog - Highly Recommended

Exeunt Magazine - Recommended

Act Three - The Reviews - Highly Recommended

On Stage Blog - Highly Recommended

NJ.com - Somewhat Recommended

Broadway and Me - Highly Recommended

(25 Reviews)
Walter Kerr Theatre

Hamilton

Hamilton

NY Daily News - Highly Recommended

Associated Press - Highly Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Highly Recommended

Vulture - Recommended

NY1 - Highly Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

USA Today - Highly Recommended

New York Post - Recommended

Newsday - Highly Recommended

amNY - Highly Recommended

Wall Street Journal - Highly Recommended

NorthJersey - Highly Recommended

Washington Post - Highly Recommended

Chicago Tribune - Highly Recommended

Time Out New York - Highly Recommended

The Wrap - Highly Recommended

Deadline - Highly Recommended

Talkin Broadway - Somewhat Recommended

Cititour.com - Highly Recommended

American Theater Web - Highly Recommended

TheaterMania - Highly Recommended

TheaterScene.net - Highly Recommended

Theatre Is Easy - Highly Recommended

Huffington Post - Highly Recommended

Theatre Reviews Limited - Highly Recommended

DC Theatre Scene - Highly Recommended

As Her World Turns - Highly Recommended

The Clyde Fitch Report - Highly Recommended

WNBC - Highly Recommended

Broadway World - Highly Recommended

(30 Reviews)
Richard Rodgers Theatre

The Lion King

The Lion King

The New York Times - Recommended

Associated Press - Highly Recommended

Vulture - Somewhat Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

USA Today - Somewhat Recommended

Entertainment Weekly - Highly Recommended

Newsday - Highly Recommended

Time Out New York - Highly Recommended

NY Magazine - Recommended

Time Magazine - Highly Recommended

Los Angeles Times - Recommended

CurtainUp - Highly Recommended

TheaterMania - Somewhat Recommended

Broadway Voice - Highly Recommended

NJ.com - Recommended

Family Vacation Critic - Highly Recommended

Street Directory - Recommended

Plain Dealer - Recommended

Syracuse Herald Journal - Somewhat Recommended

Seattle Post-Intelligencer - Recommended

Virginian Pilot - Recommended

Denver Post - Highly Recommended

Sarasota Herald Tribune - Recommended

Press-Enterprise - Recommended

Post and Courier - Highly Recommended

Flying the Nest - Recommended

Record - Highly Recommended

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - Highly Recommended

Washington Times - Recommended

Columbus Dispatch - Recommended

St. Petersburg Times - Highly Recommended

(31 Reviews)
Minskoff Theatre

MJ The Musical

MJ The Musical

The New York Times - Somewhat Recommended

NY Daily News - Recommended

Associated Press - Somewhat Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Recommended

Vulture - Not Recommended

Variety - Somewhat Recommended

New York Post - Recommended

Washington Post - Recommended

Time Out New York - Somewhat Recommended

The Wrap - Not Recommended

TheaterMania - Highly Recommended

Stage and Cinema - Highly Recommended

Broadway News - Somewhat Recommended

Theatrely - Somewhat Recommended

Cultural Daily - Somewhat Recommended

(15 Reviews)
Neil Simon Theatre

Moulin Rouge!

Moulin Rouge!

The New York Times - Highly Recommended

Hollywood Reporter - Highly Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

amNY - Not Recommended

Deadline - Somewhat Recommended

(5 Reviews)
Al Hirschfeld Theatre

Operation Mincemeat: A New Musical

Operation Mincemeat: A New Musical

New York Post - Somewhat Recommended

(1 Review)
John Golden Theatre

Six

Six

The New York Times - Recommended

Vulture - Highly Recommended

Variety - Highly Recommended

Time Out New York - Recommended

Broadway News - Highly Recommended

(5 Reviews)
Lena Horne Theatre

Smash

Smash

The New York Times - Highly Recommended

New York Post - Not Recommended

Chicago Tribune - Not Recommended

New York City Theater - Somewhat Recommended

StageZine - Recommended

The Observer - Recommended

(6 Reviews)
Imperial Theater

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

The New York Times - Recommended

New York Theater - Somewhat Recommended

New York Post - Somewhat Recommended

Washington Post - Somewhat Recommended

Chicago Tribune - Recommended

Los Angeles Times - Somewhat Recommended

(6 Reviews)
Marquis Theatre

Wicked

Wicked

The New York Times - Somewhat Recommended

NY Daily News - Not Recommended

Associated Press - Recommended

NY1 - Somewhat Recommended

Variety - Somewhat Recommended

USA Today - Highly Recommended

New York Post - Recommended

Entertainment Weekly - Recommended

Bergen Record - Recommended

Wall Street Journal - Recommended

Time Out New York - Highly Recommended

NY Magazine - Not Recommended

Village Voice - Not Recommended

The Journal News - Highly Recommended

New Yorker - Somewhat Recommended

Time Magazine - Recommended

CurtainUp - Somewhat Recommended

Talkin Broadway - Not Recommended

New York Observer - Highly Recommended

TheaterMania - Recommended

Theatre Is Easy - Recommended

New Jersey Star-Ledger - Highly Recommended

Front Row Center - Recommended

NJ.com - Highly Recommended

Journal News - Highly Recommended

New York Sun - Recommended

Daily Beast - Recommended

About Entertainment - Highly Recommended

(28 Reviews)
George Gershwin Theatre

See which of these above shows are the top rated by going to the "Top Rated Broadway Shows" page.

We pull New York Theatre reviews from many different sources and aggregate them here so you can easily see what the hot shows are and to help you decide what show in the New York area you should see and which ones have the best theatre reviews in New York!

Top Plays In Town

Go to the "Top Rated Broadway Shows" page and see what plays are getting the best reviews by the critics in New York.
Top Rated Broadway Shows arrow