The New York Times - Recommended
"Ms. Errico is, if anything, even more persuasive as Sharon, an Irish lass newly arrived on American soil, than when I saw her in the role a dozen years ago...The score, by Burton Lane and E. Y. Harburg, is one of the most enduringly delicious ever concocted for an American musical. The book, by Mr. Harburg and Fred Saidy, is more perishable, a mix of high whimsy and topical satire...Ms. Moore has come up with a very companionable interpretation."
New York Theater - Recommended
"A four-piece orchestra and a 13-member cast led by the glorious Melissa Errico do delicious justice to the show's terrific tuneful melodies...Given the music, we should be grateful that Irish Rep artistic director Charlotte Moore was willing (as both director and adapter) to wrestle with a book, by Harburg and Fred Saidy, that could hardly be more problematic or unwieldy...What's most memorable are the melodies."
NY1 - Recommended
"If the trimmed book seems rather incoherent now, the glorious score, sung so beautifully here, more than makes up for any narrative shortcomings...While Harburg and Fred Saidy's book deserves praise for its combination of whimsy and a socially responsible message, it's also pretty convoluted. That likely explains why director Moore focused her attentions on the music...Each number is a thoroughly crafted gem...And the company, cast for their sublime voices, sing their hearts out."
Wall Street Journal - Highly Recommended
"So delightful that the run of the show has already been extended...Moore requested and received permission to drastically revise the show...All that's left is its bare bones. This puts the score right where it belongs, at center stage, and it does so without destroying the dramatic continuity that's needed to make the show cohere....You won't hear better singing—or better songs—on any New York stage...All of the songs in the show make the strongest possible impression."
Time Out New York - Recommended
"Plotwise, it's sentimental blarney...The glorious songs—which make up most of the two-hour run time thanks to director Charlotte Moore's judicious book cuts—should win you over...The 13, un-amplfied cast members are in superb voice throughout...There's no denying that this is a modest mounting due to the company's budget and small stage...And yet, this seems to be the ideal way to experience 'Finian's' ample charms."
CurtainUp - Highly Recommended
"It's a revival that's handsomely spruced up and well appointed with talent to fit their smartly renovated twenty-second street theater...Still an intimate production but with richer staging and some fine tuning...The golden-voiced, very pretty Melissa Errico is not too old to play the romantic lead, and her voice is as golden as ever...The ensemble features some terrific belters...My wish for all of you reading this is that you'll find time to see this grand old musical fairy tale."
Talkin Broadway - Recommended
"A joyous, colorful revival...Watching Charlotte Moore's small-scale (13-actor) but big-hearted spin on this work, it's hard to care too much about the babblings of any nattering naysayers. This is, admittedly, mostly thanks to the score, which ranks as one of the very best ever composed for a Broadway musical...Its underlying story...is pretty hefty stuff...Traditional tropes are at play, of course...It still works when treated as honestly and forthrightly as Moore does here."
Cititour.com - Recommended
"The show's book has been substantially cut, but its satire and political commentary remain intact. That said, I do think some of it's all been laid on just a tad too thick...Still, it's the stunning score you'll most take notice of here...Choreographer Barry McNabb uses the small stage well to allow some lovely dancing interludes (including a sweet solo for Woodruff), while the four-piece orchestra adds depth to Josh Clayton's orchestrations."
TheaterMania - Highly Recommended
"Moore captures the magic within Burton Lane, Yip Harburg, and Fred Saidy's 1947 classic with great immediacy...A scrappy affair that captures the heart and soul of the material without going over the top...Best of all, the compactness of this production allows the company to perform the matchless score unamplified...With Errico, Silverman, Grovey, and company front and center, sounding like a cast of 50 rather than 13, this 'Finian's Rainbow' is downright glorious."
TheaterScene.net - Highly Recommended
"The Irish Repertory Theatre revival of ‘Finian's Rainbow' proves that it gets better with age. This social comment story wedded to Irish blarney remains a delightful musical comedy with a message, one about the evils of racism, a very timely topic which never seems to get old. Led by the charming Melissa Errico and the stalwart Ryan Silverman, Charlotte Moore's production with a cast of 13 is a marvel of economy, though you never feel that it is a small offering."
Edge New York - Recommended
"'Finian's Rainbow' is chockablock with sweet, near to saccharine songs that we all know from grandparents or a dusky bar…But what this reviewer didn't know was that the script was also tackling Jim Crow segregation, racism, and the hope necessary to conquer it. Therefore this is the perfect piece to see post the election of a man who espoused a return to a time that this piece is cautioning and arguing against."
Huffington Post - Recommended
"The inherent glint-in-the-eye charm of 'Finian' is simply but solidly captured by the folks, onstage and offstage, at the Irish Rep...Even with a good deal of trimming, the message comes through...Errico gives the friendly and melodic leading lady performance you would expect from her. Silverman is perfectly cast as Woody; while Evans makes a strong local debut and knocks the show cold with his 'When I'm Not Near the Girl I Love'...This pint-size 'Finian' scores on many levels."
NY Theatre Guide - Recommended
"Even in Irish Rep's less-than-perfect rendering, the material resonates as it hasn't in years. Alas, 'Finian's Rainbow' is relevant again...It's one of the most left-leaning classic musicals around, and seeing it, you can understand why Harburg was blacklisted not long after. In Irish Rep's staging, though, some of the book goes missing, and the political arguments are somewhat devitalized...Luckily, it's one of the great scores...'Finian's Rainbow' once again speaks directly and eloquently."
Theatre Reviews Limited - Somewhat Recommended
"'Finian's Rainbow' is as relevant and 'groundbreaking' as it was in 1947...Burton Lane's music is sumptuous and is the star of this Irish Rep production...The ensemble cast is outstanding and supports the principal actors with sheer perfection...Despite the overall stellar performances, this production of 'Finian's Rainbow' falls flat and it is not easy to determine why...Perhaps this matrix of lackluster creative team support affected the entire performance?"
Broadway Blog - Highly Recommended
"This 1947 hit is guilty of occasional silliness and simplistic racial politics (once considered radically progressive). Nonetheless, it never stops pleasing as a tuneful, socially conscious, romantic fantasy laced with moonbeams, a leprechaun, rainbows, and a crock of gold...the cast consistently delivers with affecting conviction and charm, led by the marvelous Melissa Errico, bringing beauty, assurance, happiness, and a gorgeous voice to her every moment."
Theater Pizzazz - Recommended
"A delicious and delightful antidote to the harsh realities we've been suffering. And what better way to provide social commentary than in satire and glorious song...Director Moore has adapted the book, avoiding any datedness and updating the book to a more fable-like approach – without losing the bite. Moore also keeps the pace moving briskly, wisely utilizing every inch of the stage, giving the production a rewarding fulsomeness...The score is a pot of gold that needs no burying."
Woman Around Town - Somewhat Recommended
"Songs are still swell, though somewhat thinner due to a small cast, the two attitudes/subjects remain strange bedfellows, and the piece has been so condensed that its romance proceeds with enough speed to give you whiplash...To my mind, the find of the evening is Lyrica Woodruff (Susan the Silent). The performer is utterly captivating...Director Charlotte Moore has a painterly feel for creating pictures, whether still or moving."
Times Square Chronicles - Highly Recommended
"'Finian's Rainbow' has a score and a message that is perfect for today's wounded hearts. The revival at the Irish Rep will put some of that spring back into your step and give you hope...With a book by 'Yip' Harburg and Fred Saidy that normally stalls, director Charlotte Moore has adapted the show for a hipper, more music-driven show, which is incandescently lyrical. The cast all posses gorgeous instruments."
ZEALnyc - Recommended
"The score features an unequaled collection of absolutely sterling songs, each one more melodic and appealing than the previous one…The show's book is another story...The libretto plods along from scene to scene, without any apparent forward motor to the plot…Director Moore and choreographer Barry McNabb make the most of the tiny stage, and the results are sometimes quite lively…Most of the featured performers seem to have been born to sing these songs."
Motherhood Later - Recommended
"The luminous and ageless Melissa Errico turns in a lustrous and lusty performance in this enchanting, trimmed-down, revival production of the timeless classic ‘Finian's Rainbow.' Staged in the intimate space of Irish Rep, the two-hour musical projects a warmth and intimacy well-suited to the charms of the romantic fable…The lush score has many song beauties…Errico and Silverman are well-matched, both in looks and voice, and have some truly lovely duets."
