The New York Times - Recommended
"As staged by Mr. Wolfe and Mr. Glover routines first performed nearly a century ago come across as defiantly fresh...What's new in this 'Shuffle Along' is the part written by Mr. Wolfe, and it's what feels stalest...The clunky, shoehorned-in exposition doesn't overwhelm the sweeping grace of ‘Shuffle Along' whenever it sings or dances...Ms. McDonald is a one-woman time machine de luxe, who translates the precise stylistic quirks of a bygone era into a melting immediacy."
NY Daily News - Recommended
"When the cast is singing and tearing up the floor with choreographer Savion Glover's muscular and thrilling tap-dancing it's pure unmitigated heaven. But between numbers...the narration turns entertainment into dull lecture hall...Mitchell, Porter, Dixon and Henry are terrific. But the ace in the hole in this enterprise is Audra McDonald...Even though the narration lacks drama, the tap-happy new show gleams with ambition and topnotch talent."
Associated Press - Recommended
"It's not a review or revival. It's more like a history lesson that will blow you away...There is a bit of bloat, too much exposition and with five stars who each need a backstory, the plot sometimes slows, but Wolfe nicely captures the timeless craziness of creation and the glory days of a special show."
Hollywood Reporter - Recommended
"Scene after scene dazzles in one of the most electrifying entertainments on Broadway...While the showmanship is extraordinary, ‘Shuffle Along' could have benefited from a developmental run to hone the fluidity of its storytelling...The project's strengths far outweigh its flaws. The cast is magnificent...The energy and elasticity of Glover's work is astonishing…Even if the limitations of Wolfe's undertaking are unable to support the scope of his intentions, it's a genuine thrill to watch."
Vulture - Highly Recommended
"Wolfe bombards a core of ideas about race and culture with a billion showbiz protons to produce both a gorgeous spectacle and a big, smoking crater where your former ideas of Broadway once stood...If much of Act Two is a PowerPoint presentation, with astonishing slides but bullet-point arguments, the show as a whole is nevertheless life-changing theater. To the extent Wolfe has redeemed the lost artists of 'Shuffle Along,' he has also redeemed himself, and us."
Variety - Somewhat Recommended
"An incoherent book seems a small price to pay for the joy of watching Audra McDonald cut loose...McDonald takes the role and does everything in this show but fly...But what the first act giveth, the second act taketh away...At this point, the show is actively fighting with itself...It's understandable that Wolfe would fall for this rich material, but he really should have stopped himself from cramming it all into this show."
USA Today - Highly Recommended
"In this season of ‘Hamilton,' it's been a tall order for any new Broadway production to rise to the level of an event. But ‘Shuffle Along' qualifies...The stars, all excellent, provide portraits that are at once recognizably human and lavishly entertaining...The new ‘Shuffle Along' also benefits, greatly, from the exuberant gifts of choreographer Savion Glover...Exhilarating."
Entertainment Weekly - Highly Recommended
"A refreshing burst of energy, no caffeine necessary...Glover's rhythmic tap is the true pulse of ‘Shuffle Along'. The clickety-clacks heard from 30-plus dancers at once ignite every seat in the theater and quickly become the only beat we need, hold the orchestra...A dazzling production that celebrates art, dreams, and equality. And when the man behind me emphatically screamed out, 'Damn!' after the final number, I had to nod my head and agree."
Newsday - Recommended
"A bold and wistful, playful and important musical-about-a-musical. It is overstuffed with ambition and talent, sure, but why shouldn't it be?...There is a lot of exposition, a few too many back stories and, every so often, the narrative inertia of an illustrated history. But what illustrations these are, choreographed for the terrific dancing chorus by Glover with both a combination of the dazzling, syncopated black-tapping tradition and his own special full-footed, stomping identity."
amNY - Recommended
"A hot mess of the highest caliber—a dazzling and dizzying documentary mixed with star turns, syncopated rhythms, stylish attire, fierce tap-dancing and weak subplots...The storytelling is chaotic and choppy, and the characters are painted in broad strokes. The second act, set after the show has become an overnight sensation, comes off as superfluous...Still, there's no denying its thrills and palpable excitement."
Wall Street Journal - Somewhat Recommended
"The first half of ‘Shuffle Along' is the musical you've got to see...Savion Glover's near-nonstop choreography explodes off the stage with the unrelenting impact of a flamethrower. But then comes intermission, and what had looked like a masterpiece goes flat and stays that way...While Mr. Wolfe has failed to weld the parts of ‘Shuffle Along' into a convincing whole, his directorial touch is otherwise as sure as ever."
NorthJersey - Highly Recommended
"Mitchell, Porter, Dixon and Henry are all top-rung Broadway performers, and invest their characters with distinctive personalities, as well as singing in their own special styles...But as in every show in which she appears, McDonald stands out...She's proved that she can do anything, superbly...You leave 'Shuffle Along' with the feeling that if everyone tap-danced, the world would be a much happier place."
Washington Post - Somewhat Recommended
"The goals of correcting the record so vie for primacy with the values of first-class entertainment in this vibrant, didactic, at times breathtaking and other times slightly condescending enterprise that you sense a war still raging over what exactly the show is striving to be...Were it not for the array of talent assembled here ‘Shuffle Along' might feel too unresolved and heavy-handed….It does come across as a message-laden exercise. The joy here is lessened by the lesson."
Chicago Tribune - Highly Recommended
"It is no mean feat to revive an archaic Broadway musical and create an entertainment that not only celebrates the classic material but ennobles it further...It is a yet-greater achievement to simultaneously offer what is essentially a lesson in theatrical and racial history... 'Shuffle Along,' has achieved all of this....It suffers from the scale of what it has attempted...An exceptionally important new show...'Shuffle' does all that historical stuff while putting on one helluva tap show."
Time Out New York - Highly Recommended
"The first half is sensational; the second is difficult...But with a cast this incandescent and Wolfe staging a constant flow of miracles, there's an overflow of joy and style that smooths over stylistic rough edges and knotty stitching of history to myth...We can luxuriate in a breathtaking piece of showmanship, featuring more talent crowding a stage than pretty much any other Broadway show at present (and yes, that includes 'Hamilton')."
The Wrap - Highly Recommended
"A very didactic approach, but whenever their words threaten to turn into a Wikipedia entry, Wolfe the writer hands the reins to his better half: Wolfe the director, with an assist from Savion Glover the choreographer. Both have no equal on Broadway this season. In a year of pandering, corn-pone musicals, ‘Shuffle Along' exudes elegance and intelligence at every turn. While it's big in its ambitions, theatrical thrills, and the emotions it stirs, Wolfe achieves much in very small ways."
Village Voice - Recommended
"The talent keeps coming at you. There's strong music and movement by a crackerjack ensemble; enduring songs; and blizzards of Glover's tap choreography, historically on point and inventive...There's not much of a book — the original show had a bad one, and Wolfe's replacement doesn't triumph...Essentially a lecture-demonstration with spectacular production values, 'Shuffle Along' should claim a berth on Broadway for at least as long as 'The Lion King.'"
Financial Times - Recommended
"The Pirandellian meta-musical is at once an old-fashioned all-singing, all-dancing extravaganza and a thoughtful meditation on the history of race relations…The real star power comes from Audra McDonald, a Broadway legend playing a 1920s version of herself with infectious exuberance and sass…Wolfe lays on the exposition a little thick at times. But his 'Shuffle' is a courageous work on many levels...Their story reminds us that, once the music stops, life does just shuffle along."
The Guardian - Somewhat Recommended
"A sometimes inspired and sometimes listless exploration of a path-breaking theatrical work...Despite the excellence of the leads, it comes to seem as much a lecture-demonstration as a drama. This 'Shuffle Along' is sometimes edifying and sometimes entertaining, but rarely do these twin aims coincide...It's only when the feet are tapping, the fringe is swaying and the voices of the leads and chorus are celebrating the thrill of syncopation that the musical lives again."
Deadline - Somewhat Recommended
"An idea is not a focal point, and so 'Shuffle Along' never resolves into a story. Instead, it's a series of historical scenes that tell, rather than show, and that's deadly for a musical. It's unquestionably entertaining to watch the five principal actors here at work, none less than consummate...And yet 'Shuffle Along' struck me as both rough and unfinished...The show is conceptually flawed, and it's hard to tell whether that ever can be resolved."
Los Angeles Times - Recommended
"Never has anything this educational been so sensationally staged...The powerhouse stage presences of Wolfe's actors have to compensate for characters who are only incompletely sketched...What ‘Shuffle Along' lacks in drama it makes up for in sophisticated showmanship...The second best new musical of the Broadway year...The beauty, poignancy and breathtaking verve of this production are the product of a unique solidarity between troupers of different eras."
CurtainUp - Recommended
"George C. Wolfe's combination of putting-on-a-show story and history lesson about the groundbreaking contributions of the 'Shuffle Along' team to musical theater has so many riches that it's easy to forgive its somewhat disappointing execution of the 'All That Followed' second act...Brilliantly choreographed by Savion Glover with a large, to-die-for, top-to-bottom cast...'Shuffle Along' is a most enjoyable, invigorating new look at a savory and worth thinking about slice of musical history."
Talkin Broadway - Recommended
"It's a thrilling kaleidoscope, both comfortable and unpredictable...Glover's work is electrifying, but the arrangements and orchestrations of Daryl Waters so meld together the musical bits and pieces into one seamless whole that they might be more amazing and integral...The second act, charting the 'All That Followed' chunk of the title, lacks the dynamic narrative thrust of the first, and struggles to maintain the same vibrancy, only regaining it in full for the finale."
Cititour.com - Recommended
"A history lesson wrapped in a vivid theatrical entertainment wrapped in a rebuke...It may be too much, but you most definitely don't want to live without it!...Wolfe stunningly recreates numbers from the show onstage and backstage, with the invaluable help of the magnificent tap choreography of Savion Glover...The show's second act fares slightly less well, as it gives us more of a paint-by-numbers recap of the fates of these characters...Get tickets while they last."
TheaterMania - Highly Recommended
"It's an enchanting night on old Broadway, overflowing with talent and kept in constant motion by the brilliant choreography of Savion Glover... It's not a typical Broadway musical by any means, and that is a good thing...Glover exceeds all expectations with his heart-pounding and scrupulously constructed choreography, executed with flawless precision by the ensemble...It keeps this two-hour-45-minute show from ever dragging."
Show Showdoen - Recommended
"Some of the best dancing you'll see on a Broadway stage this season (or any), and a top-notch cast featuring some of the most well-known and beloved stars of the genre. There are some truly stunning production numbers, some laugh-out-loud gags, and a lot of warmth. I couldn't stop smiling through the entire first act, and while I struggled more with the second, I'd hardly call it a crashing bore by any stretch."
TheaterScene.net - Recommended
"Witnessing the struggles and victories of the principal characters in 'Shuffle Along' is exciting, not to mention mind-bogglingly entertaining...The collaboration of Wolfe and choreographer Savion Glover is inspired, although even they and their craft can't quite relieve the heavy-handed story line and moralizing...The choreography is simply superb, not only recreating the era's cheery virtuosity, but giving it a fresh, contemporary spin, performed by an expert, youthful cast."
Huffington Post - Highly Recommended
"The Broadway season ends with a theatrical explosion from George C. Wolfe and Savion Glover...Add in a half-dozen stellar performances, a sterling production, and an astoundingly talented ensemble and you have a musical that moves in a manner we haven't seen since ‘Dreamgirls'...It is the combination of Wolfe and Glover that makes ‘Shuffle Along' a veritable explosion of theatricality, an unorthodox and vital new-style Broadway feast."
Theatre Reviews Limited - Recommended
"The first act is pretty much pure joy from start to finish...It is chock-full of dancing, song, dazzling costumes, and you could probably leave at intermission and feel totally satisfied…George C. Wolfe is a more dazzling director than succinct writer. You can almost feel the energy dissipating as we get near the end, but the performers just keep keeping on…It's not perfect and it's not the game changer the original was. But I hope it stays put for a long time."
DC Theatre Scene - Recommended
"It is cataclysmically entertaining...Glover's thrilling choreography is enough alone to make the show worth seeing...Wolfe's ambition to tell the story behind the musical...quickly starts feeling as if he were a PhD student defending his thesis about the significance of this 'sadly neglected' musical...Luckily, Wolfe the savvy showman often wins out over Wolfe the pedant, and there are moments of ‘Shuffle Along' that are as electrifying and sublime as any this season on Broadway."
Towle Road - Recommended
"Wolfe brilliantly explores important questions about race, power, and representation...While it's easy to invest in the talented stars and the history they're unearthing, ‘Shuffle' is not necessarily character-driven, so when their personal fates become the focus, the results are somewhat less compelling. All the same…‘Shuffle' itself feels like a long-overdue celebration — of Black artists and Black Broadway history."
WNBC - Somewhat Recommended
"‘Shuffle Along' is stylized to evoke an era and focus on big scenes, which can become burdened with exposition...These necessities push individual personalities into the background, which keeps us from getting to know better the ensemble...Choreographer Glover brings to life elaborate tap sequences…‘Shuffle Along' is moving, in fits and starts, as a story about artists who risk their critical and financial fortunes...instead of toning down that spirit for mass consumption."
Bobs Theater Blog - Recommended
"Wolfe keeps the show moving energetically. It is the book, also by Wolfe, that I found wanting. The story of mounting a show against all obstacles seems clichéd...With five main protagonists, there is too little time to develop any of them very deeply…Nevertheless, you won't find more talent on one stage anywhere else on Broadway. With all the book's flaws, the story represents an important piece of theater history and black history that should not be forgotten."
StageZine - Recommended
"Act I is entertainment of dizzying heights. Act II plods with the usual heavy-handed dialogue that only George C. Wolfe can churn out. What a blissful, deliriously enjoyable and heavenly evening could have been achieved had the director Wolfe toned down the lugubriously preachy writings of writer Wolfe...However, the evening's real hero is Savion Glover...In large part due to Mr. Glover's vision, this heavy-handed musical soars into the stratosphere."
ZEALnyc - Not Recommended
"A cast of Broadway's biggest talents dazzle in the disappointing 'Shuffle Along'...There is so much to love about this re-imagining of Eubie Blake and Noble Sissle's ground-breaking 1921 Broadway musical...Where 'Shuffle Along' fails, and quite spectacularly given the talent associated with the project, is in the show's book...Wolfe fails to wrench a theatrical journey from a single point...A noble effort. But just because it happened, doesn't make it interesting."
NJ.com - Recommended
"This proudly flashy, impressively ambitious show is the very last production to open in the 2015-16 Broadway season. Talk about finishing on a high note...Sometimes bites off more than it can chew...After the rousing first act, the second act seems to meander...But what a dream team Wolfe has assembled here, and what unadulterated joy they evince at being able to perform together."
BroadwaySelect - Somewhat Recommended
"I was galvanized by what Wolfe had to say and show — until intermission. Wolfe's Act Two dealt with my bugaboo: 'Shuffle Along' collaborators' personal lives...If we're to learn about "the making of the musical," we need to hear and process that information; making our heads work in tennis-match fashion by going from one speaker to another, trying to find who's talking now, making each line harder to hear results in a far less enjoyable and informative show."
