The New York Times - Highly Recommended
"The musical is gentle-spirited, not gaudy, and moves with an easygoing grace where others prance and strut. And it tells a sentiment-spritzed story...While the story certainly skirts (if not embraces) sentimentality and the overripeness of melodrama, the production's soft-hued style keeps it from curdling into treacle. The songs boast simple but seductive melodies, and lyrics that have a sweet, homespun quality. The mostly acoustic score is beautifully played."
NY Daily News - Somewhat Recommended
"The show isn't a bullseye. But it's sweet and tender and boasts a fine cast...Martin and Brickell's bluegrassy score is mellow and pretty. But it's also repetitive — melodically and lyrically...The show could have cut some too...Director Walter Bobbie and choreographer Josh Rhodes keep the show chugging along. An elevated toy train set adds amusing atmosphere...Cusack, a Broadway rookie, consistently shines — even when 'Bright Star' doesn't."
Associated Press - Not Recommended
"The show never hits an honest note and seems to have been written by two people who adore classic Broadway musicals but who have intentionally decided to make a third-rate version. The music is weak...The book and lyrics are even more feeble, with graceless lines and weird characters...The show, so long exploring lost love, then descends into virtual farce before ending on such a forced happy note and with such swiftness that it'll knock the corndog out of your hand."
Hollywood Reporter - Somewhat Recommended
"There's a disarming sweetness and sincerity to this folksy Americana bluegrass musical which makes the tuneful melodrama a pleasurable experience. It also helps that talented lead Carmen Cusack brings such integrity and warmth to her performance...Brickell's lyrics lack imagination and specificity, and can seem awkwardly pasted onto gentle melodies that at times become a little samey...It's easy to overlook the shortcomings of the musical's craft and go with its sweet-natured optimism."
Vulture - Somewhat Recommended
"'Bright Star' is a banal, self-cancelling, upbeat musical, the kind that wants to demonstrate a lot of heart without actually having one. Which is not to say it has no smarts and no value. There's a lot to like in 'Bright Star' and a lot to admire in the way it was made...How the stories intersect with the songs is the larger problem here. The mostly bluegrass score sounds great but almost always does exactly the opposite of what a story-based musical requires."
NY1 - Somewhat Recommended
"Initially, there are enjoyable elements. The onstage band is lively and quick-fingered, and director Walter Bobbie's overall production has a fresh, whimsical feel...Sadly, Edie Brickell's awkward and obvious lyrics are hobbled by cheap rhymes...You will see the eleventh-hour revelations coming from a country mile away...Steve Martin's jaunty bluegrass score may get your toes tapping, but only if the sappy and sketchy plot does not drive you out at intermission."
Variety - Somewhat Recommended
"'Bright Star' is Broadway-slick, with top-rung creatives involved and an appealing lead performance from Carmen Cusack. But the sheer scale of the package overwhelms this sweet but slender homespun material...Martin is an accomplished banjo player and the music he writes with Brickell sounds completely authentic...they also sound repetitive...The big drawback to the chatty lyrics is that they re-hash the plot's melodramatic content, but neglect to deepen or explore the characters."
USA Today - Recommended
"'Bright Star' aspires to the kind of emotional sweep and folksy wit we associate with Golden Age musicals...Martin captures some of that old-school spirit with a book that's as forthright as it is smart, funny and charming...The score poses a few challenges...Some of the more delicate ballads seem to strain for theatricality...The tone in which that story is delivered can also wobble a bit, especially later on...Still this gently shining 'Star' holds its own."
New York Post - Somewhat Recommended
"The weird thing about 'Bright Star' is the way it juxtaposes an over-the-top plot with a low-key production and mild-tempered music...The show ambles along, alternating between lively hootenannies and lovely ditties...The show's droll, earnest tone does have its appeal. Fans of Martin's humor will find evidence of it here...As a gentle fable, 'Bright Star' has a quirky charm, but its stubborn refusal to face up to its dark side diminishes it."
Entertainment Weekly - Recommended
"'Bright Star' often verges on corny, particularly in the second act as the plotlines come together. The set is unfussy but suits the story well...But it's Martin and Brickell's music that's the brightest star in 'Bright Star'. The bluegrass sounds complement the show's setting and era, Americana music with layered harmonies and beautiful use of banjo and fiddle. Not every song is a winner, but there are stirring ballads and toe-tapping numbers throughout that audience members will enjoy."
Newsday - Highly Recommended
"It doesn't shy away from the cornball or the unapologetically sentimental. And, yes, the plot is implausibly romantic and hinged on coincidence. Along with all that, however, 'Bright Star' is also downright wonderful...As the relationships deepen and darken, the show grows with the complexity of a juicy short story...Then there's the score, which builds with rhythmic surprises, melodic complexity and the deep satisfaction of humming and plucking strings."
amNY - Recommended
"'Bright Star' is a total anomaly. It's wholly original and unashamedly sentimental and romantic, with a country-folk score and no well-known actors in the cast...The storytelling can be jumbled, improbable and sappy, and the characters are undeveloped. Nevertheless, it is a heartwarming and crowd-pleasing musical, sporting many pleasant country songs, a sunny disposition and a Southern Gothic flavor."
Wall Street Journal - Not Recommended
"Martin is a good banjo player who writes not-so-great plays. Now he's branched out by writing a really bad bluegrass-pop musical...The best thing about 'Bright Star' is the music, which is bland and undramatic but competently wrought. The plot is trite, the dialogue humorless and stiff, the lyrics stupefyingly banal. The cast and band work hard and Bobbie does his best to breathe life into the show, but if Martin's name weren't on the marquee, it wouldn't have gotten anywhere near Broadway."
Chicago Tribune - Recommended
"Martin forged score, book and story for this wholly original musical—a piece that, despite its tonal unevenness and frequent, needless diversions from truth, still feels like a significant, distinctive and artful entry into the Broadway repertory...It would be an even-better thing if this show acknowledged the racial complexities of the era of its setting...A moving story that got under my skin despite some resistance, and a score that elevates the Broadway-bluegrass fusion."
Time Out New York - Not Recommended
"'Bright Star' aspires to be what the older Alice asks from a young fiction writer: 'a sweeping tale of pain and redemption'. But it cries out for an editor's sharp blue pen. Sweeping? In lieu of the color that the story seems to call for, Bobbie's production is often actively plain...Painful? For the audience, perhaps...It does, however, have a genuine redeeming feature in Cusack...If not much else, the musical does right by its star, the bright spot in a sky of murk."
The Wrap - Not Recommended
"The 'Bright Star' bluegrass score features more twangs per dipthong than a whole evening of 'Tobacco Road'. This is the third bluegrass musical to open in New York City in the last two weeks. More of these and Broadway will run out of fiddles and banjos, I'm praying...Time will tell if this musical makes the walls of Joe Allen restaurant's gallery of flops. On the walls of my mind, 'Bright Star' has already taken its place between last season's 'Doctor Zhivago' and 1979's 'Got Tu Go Disco'."
Backstage - Recommended
"Though the structure and pacing of the book have serious flaws, the dialogue itself is sharp, witty, and dripping with appropriate Southern colloquialisms. The score, both homey and evocative, is hands down the best I've heard in a show that uses the country vernacular. Walter Bobbie's direction is as swift and seamless as the clunky book will allow, using stylized movement rather than codified dance to express the melodies and transition between timelines and scenes."
The Guardian - Somewhat Recommended
"'Bright Star' is still suffering some issues of scale. The story it tells is a small and tender one and the staging and the music, playful and lovely, sometimes struggle to fill the house...If there are a few too many numbers here, nearly all of them are sparkish...Cusack is nuanced and forceful...Paul Alexander Nolan plays her one-time lover and it's a treat to see him in what initially is a more playful role...Their combined energy and allure lend the musical lustre."
Deadline - Not Recommended
"Skip 'Bright Star,' the unfortunate musical...this earnest but soggy mess. 'Bright Star' reeks of condescension, from the twangy accents to the charm layered on like dollar perfume and the thigh-slapping slap-happy dances...However, the songs are, in and of themselves, striking...But nothing really takes flight in 'Bright Star'. It's as earthbound as the folks it wants to celebrate."
CurtainUp - Recommended
"'Bright Star' is unlikely to become part of the canon of groundbreaking musicals with memorably meaningful stories. But, it's chockablock with assets to make for an enjoyable, feel-good two hours...So give in to 'Bright Star's' charms, as I did, and let the nitpickers complain. Yes, it's headed from the get-go to an inevitably happy ending that relies on some pretty far-fetched contrivances...But with Carmen Cusack as Alice, this is your chance to see a-star-is-born Broadway debut."
Talkin Broadway - Not Recommended
"Despite the vibrant life pulsating from the bluegrass that underscores 'Bright Star' the overwhelming feeling that emanates from this new musical is the exhaustion of cliché...The chief problem here is that, outside of the delightful music, there's nothing new in either the story or the telling of it that energizes the drama...Cusack is a coruscating force of nature as Alice...It's not enough to elevate the evening above the pedestrian."
Cititour.com - Not Recommended
"A certain percentage of theatergoers won't really be able to get past Martin's overly earnest, structurally muddled and often tonally questionable libretto...Cusack flawlessly embodies Murphy in both periods with grit and vulnerability, which goes a long way to helping us overlook the show's flaws...As for Martin and Brickell's score, it pleases the ear on first listening...That's why I am glad they still make CDs, because I really couldn't make it through a second viewing of 'Bright Star.'"
American Theater Web - Recommended
"It's a sweet, romantic, sepia-toned look back to the first half of the 20th century that's beautifully supported by the score Martin and Brickell have written...Director Walter Bobbie, working with choreographer Josh Rhodes, deploys the structure that houses the band to help give the show a sweeping cinematic feel...The appealingly tuneful journey to the show's conclusion proves to be consistently satisfying and ultimately moving."
TheaterMania - Recommended
"Those in the market for an old-fashioned, feel-good show should check out 'Bright Star,' Steve Martin and Edie Brickell's charming but somewhat underdeveloped new musical...The rhymes are often forced and the lyrics repetitive...Luckily, the delightful bluegrass music keeps us blissfully distracted most of the time...Judging from the moist eyes that surrounded me, these ham-fisted oversights won't do much to dampen the enjoyment Broadway audiences get from Bright Star, a joyous new show."
TheaterScene.net - Somewhat Recommended
"'Bright Star' rises—just barely—above Hallmark Network romance level thanks to its energetic score...and an astonishing, charismatic performance by Carmen Cusack...The problem is that an evening of bluegrass and banjo strumming can verge on the monotonous...Brickell's lyrics also tend toward the repetitious and trite...Walter Bobbie keeps the pace moving without stinting on the drama or comedy. His first-rate production almost makes the surprising plot devices credible."
Epoch Times - Recommended
"There's warmth and anguish aplenty in the 'Bright Star'...Cusack turns in a dynamite performance...The score is delightful and much of it provides an authentic bluegrass feel...'Bright Star' is not perfect—the book needs work at points—but it does offer a powerful example of the effect family has on a person's life and how, when a real and honest love is added to the mix, it can be a wonderful thing indeed."
Huffington Post - Recommended
"A work of theatrical magic...The sun bops from window to window during the day; nighttime has its own sensibility. There is an urban melody here that both children and adults will enjoy. Think of a symphony of non-conceptual art — shapes, colors, shadow and light. Animation meets original music by Laurent Rochelle in a novel way. 'Cité' is whimsical and existential all at the same time. The monochromatic colors are sharp and deep, while the abstract imagery is entertaining and clever."
Theatre Reviews Limited - Recommended
"An old-fashioned Broadway musical with pleasing music, agreeable lyrics, and an engaging book...The musical's story is also universal and engaging. Its themes are important and life-affirming…The cast, under Walter Bobbie's careful direction is uniformly magnificent…'Bright Star' is not perfect–some of the story seems contrived and sometimes predictable–but director Walter Bobbie keeps the musical moving forward with an intensity and freshness that is remarkable and noteworthy."
Broadway Blog - Recommended
"Martin and Brickell's score is a celebration of American folk music, filled with soaring string arrangements...At its core, Ms. Cusack delivers a beautifully honest performance...Its final scenes may push the suspension of disbelief in a way that doesn't necessarily serve the greater story...But one dissonant chord cannot deny the show's genuine charm. 'Bright Star' delivers a unique voice in a season full of heavy hitters. Hopefully it will find its audience and continue to shine bright."
Theater Pizzazz - Recommended
"The lively hootenanny, hand- and thigh-slapping choreography is accomplished by the talents of Josh Rhodes, while director Walter Bobbie makes magic in moving this large cast around seamlessly…'Bright Star' has a down-home warmth that draws the audience into its glow, making the 2 hours, 30 minutes more than entertaining."
Stu on Broadway - Highly Recommended
"Let it suffice to say I was surprised. Pleasantly surprised. Wonderfully surprised with all aspects of the production...I wanted theater-goers to experience the musical without the filter of my critique and possibly come away exhilarated like myself. Therefore, my review is short, simple, and to the point. Go see 'Bright Star'. Be enchanted, moved, uplifted and maybe even shed a tear."
Towle Road - Somewhat Recommended
"There is something winning and infectious about 'Bright Star'...Even with a sweet ending that's predictable by intermission, its charms are enough to engage viewers along the way...The assembled cast is uniformly strong, but the show belongs to Ms. Cusack...Martin brings a clever hand to the musical's book, mixing earnest, sometimes poetic storytelling with welcome laughs...But I do have to say—and I really wish I didn't—that it's aggravatingly vanilla."
Front Row Center - Highly Recommended
"Carmen Cusack knocks the ball out of the park…You can see the conclusion coming a mile away, but the show is so exquisite in every way that you don't mind watching everything unfold...Scenes could be trimmed...The cast is a marvel of ensemble work…All in all it is an evening that will take you out of the city and off to the mysterious magic of the Appalachians for two decades of stories that will get you in all the right places: Head, heart, and all the way down to the toes of your feet."
The Clyde Fitch Report - Somewhat Recommended
"Bluegrass-y, Southern-Gothic-y 'Bright Star,' which is directed by Walter Bobbie and choreographed by Josh Rhodes with a sleekness that makes your head spin with giddy delight...When an audience member is inspired to think ahead of the creative team it can make a protracted second act that much longer. It felt like I was waiting for the inevitable to occur...On the formidable plus-side, there's much more to say of the 'Bright Star' score...Yet the real heroes here are Bobbie and Rhodes"
WNBC - Somewhat Recommended
"There's much to admire in the final product: The musical is twangy and tightly performed, with a sweeping score. My enjoyment was muted only by the mostly modest character development...Of Martin's book, I felt that too often I was being told what to feel, without being given opportunity to feel it...I'm sure there are great hopes riding on 'Bright Star'. It's not a perfect musical; this 'Star' doesn't always guide the way, but at times it beams brightly enough."
Theatres Leiter Side - Somewhat Recommended
"Enjoyable as much of it is, ‘Bright Star'...may not shine as brightly in Broadway's constellation as some of its more unique and noteworthy competitors. It'll be interesting to see if its pleasing bluegrass score, strong performances, and smart staging are enough to compensate for its thin book, melodramatically coincidental premise, stereotypical Southern-fried characters, and conventional situations."
StageZine - Somewhat Recommended
"This down-home tale has a lot going for it, from energetic choreography by Josh Rhodes to a great cast directed by Walter Bobbie and a breakout performance from golden-voiced Carmen Cusack in the lead role...If one overlooks the two things that bog down 'Bright Star'—Ms. Brickell's rhyming, often repetitious lyrics and the somewhat predictable plot—it's easy to suspend disbelief and go with the saga…Cusak brings badly needed depth and veracity to the paper-thin material."
DC Metro Theater Arts - Recommended
"I found their story engrossing, entertaining, and very moving...The music is lively, but the fiddle and the banjo can only go so far to interestingly cover some twenty songs...I thought the melodies embellished the story more than the lyrics did, but the story itself, though somewhat predictable, is neatly told and very well crafted…There isn't a lemon in this boatload of performing talent...Walter Bobbie has blended them all together into a refreshing smoothie of a musical."
Act Three - The Reviews - Recommended
"Overall, the confusion generated in Act I couldn't be forgotten, but 'Bright Star' is a solid, heartwarming story...but a bit more work is needed to turn this into a Broadway hit. Make no mistake, the cast and crew were absolutely ready for their first Broadway performance and none of the criticism here is reflective of their top notch performance."
NJ.com - Somewhat Recommended
"An unconvincing mix of tender romance and harrowing tragedy...Brickell and Martin's story features two big twists, one of them completely bizarre and implausible, and the other painfully hokey and predictable. The effect is to drain any tension from the hurried second act, and to reduce these potentially complex characters to two-dimensional pawns...Still, the music steadily delivers...And with the lovely Cusack, making her Broadway debut, a star is born."
Broadway World - Not Recommended
"The new Southern Gothic musical shows all the signs of being written by a pair who have not quite grasped some of the basics of the genre's craft...A lack of lyrical specificity plagues much of the score, limiting variety in the way the characters express themselves. When the authors do deliver a pair of dramatic second act songs to serve the storytelling, the music and lyrics are embarrassingly heavy-handed...Nice music, fine performances, but other than that, barely a twinkle."